| Review Stories |
Case Studies in Support of the MHNIP Review
The ACMHN received many submissions from credentialed mental health nurses providing services under the MHNIP when developing the MHNIP Review. Here are some of the stories that we were not able to include in the publication, but which further demonstrate the skills, expertise and strengths of the mental health nursing profession:
Julie LockI have worked in mental health in both the UK and Australia over the past 30 years, in both public and private sectors. I have worked in the MHNIP for the past 9 months, working in several different GP surgeries in Gippsland. This is one of the best jobs I have ever had. I am respected and valued. I am able to do the job I am employed to do, and believe it is making a huge difference to the people I see. I have found that the majority of patients are people who either - Have been assessed by public mental health and have not been accepted for service - Choose not to go to public mental health due to stigma - Can’t afford private help or are unable to travel the long distance to Melbourne for private mental health assistance. All of these people have a mental illness and would have previously struggled with the limited support that GP’s are able to provide. Some would have accessed limited assistance from a psychologist. Some would have simply fallen through the gaps, not receiving any help. This is an excellent programme, well over due. The only improvement I can suggest would be to increase the service. To engage all GPs into the programme. Julie Lock, Credentialed Mental Health Nurse, Working for CWG Division of General Practice. Michael Farrell-WhelanMy name is Michael Farrell-Whelan and I have worked in mental health services for the last 35 years including the last 15 years as a bereavement counsellor on a palliative care team. Just over 12 months ago my wife and I went into private practice as grief and bereavement counsellors. At the same time I became a Credentialed Mental Health Nurse and was engaged by one of the local GPs in the Blue Mountains to see mental health clients under the MHNIP. I have found the MHNIP a great project as I can case manage clients with a focus on the client rather than the bureaucracy, therefore the vast majority of my time is spent face to face with the client. It can be difficult to evaluate this project after only twelve months but anecdotally the GP has commented on having less "emergency" consultations with his mental health clients and now none of the people I see are case managed by the local mental health service.
Margaret WellsI work two jobs, one in MHNIP. Last year, I worked full time in an extremely stressful mental health job, worked in MHNIP in the evenings and on week-ends and did my second Masters degree part-time. I worked in MHNIP because of the satisfaction it provides. It has encouraged me to grow and learn more. It has provided me the opportunity to develop a broad range of skills and to work with clients in ways that are creative, generative and helpful in reciprocal ways.Clients love it, they can attend at the GPs, no one knows why they've come. I have approximately a 90 % attendance rate (clients rarely fail to attend.) They report improvements. I offer flexibility. I can work with children and adults. I work with families. I visit in their homes. I advocate for them in all types of settings. The downside is, I don't get paid enough to do this full time. Under the MHNIP scheme, I haven't had a pay rise in three years. I can earn more doing a casual shift in a hospital. I don't get professional development money. To attend a training course I lose income and pay for the course. I use my wage to purchase resources. I'm lucky to work with other MHNIPs so we have our own peer supervision together. Otherwise, there would be a risk of isolation and separateness doing this work. GP's often don't have physical room to accommodate the MHNIP and we may find ourselves doing a home visit because there is no room in the clinic, we may have to delay service provision to clients. Generally, GP's often don't realise what we are capable of, I don't think there is a broad understanding of the skills we can offer clients or GP's. Barbara PentacostI am working in the MHNIP. I started in 2008 one day a week and am now working 9 days a fortnight and the surgery is looking at taking on another MHN for 2 extra days per week. I am booked up 2 weeks in advance and there is a great need for mental health nurses fulfilling this role. It has meant that it frees the MHN’s at the hospital so they can take on a more crisis care role which in the past had to be slotted in to their already busy schedule.The support I have received from the GPs has been enabling. Working closely with them has meant a more seamless service providing the clients with greater continuity. It has also meant I have a chance to work within the community helping clients to start a Depression Support Network in a community that has nowhere at present for sufferers from Depression to go to get some peer support and activities. I feel that it gives me the chance to use my skills as a Mental Health Nurse and challenges me in a positive way each day. Barbara Pentacost , Pioneer Health, Albany, WA
Diana StephenI am a nurse with 30 years experience and now find myself in the most productive and useful phase of my career practising in the MHNIP. For years I have been nursing people whose mental state has deteriorated to such an extent that their lives have often been ruined or broken. Working in a GP clinic I now work with people who realise they need help, know they are struggling and are receptive to my knowledge and experience. In a short time I have seen people who, if the MHNIP service had not been available, would have ended up in hospital or their situation would have crumbled to the point where problems would have impacted on their families and their relationships. I have received some very positive feedback and watched some quite significant improvements. On a personal level there is a lot of positive validation and job satisfaction. On a human level it must be a benefit to have the cycle of illness interrupted before significant damage is done. It has long been an issue in health that prevention is better than the cure, and for the first time this is a reality rather than a platitude.
Noel MolloyMy name is Noel Molloy and I was Credentialed late 2010. I live and work in the Werribee area, in the West of Melbourne. This is one of the fastest growing municipalities in Australia. After 36 years in nursing, i decided that I needed a change. I have been the Clinical Nurse Manager of the Acute Adult Inpatient Unit for the past 8 years. I have been working in private practice for the past 4 months, while balancing my ‘day job’ and gradually building my referrals. I have a mixed business, also providing clinical supervision to groups and individuals. I have also helped a number of individuals to apply for their credentialing and I hope that some of them will join me in establishing a local practice. I am about to go on 7 months leave, a mixture of annual and long service. I hope to work full time in private practice. What I have enjoyed most so far is my feeling the growing sense of independence and fulfilment as a nurse, but also meeting the needs of people who ordinarily would ‘fall through the cracks’ of the public health system. I have also had a group of very supportive colleagues, who have backed me all the way, including my wife (most important!!!). Fellow college members and credentialed nurses have only been too obliging to help me navigate the system, namely Dermot Moynihan, Craig Maloney and the wonderful Nina Hunter. What has been difficult is getting GPs to refer. They are sometimes only happy to refer if you will rent a room or complete the mental health plan for them. Their documentation is in the main poor; ‘please see ABC for xyz’ is the total referral. Yet in the local area they are crying out for services…….Some do not understand the MHNIP and therefore don’t refer. Some do not understand when you reply to their question ‘what can you do for me?’ with the answer ‘ add value to your service!’. The paperwork for reimbursement is painful and I feel we should be paid directly, not through a third party. I know the College is pursuing this, but waiting three months to get paid is difficult if the ‘third party’ or you miss the submission deadline. All in all, the positives far outweigh the negatives. I have found that I have to become a ‘salesman’ of sorts, selling my services, which has made me realise how undervalued we rate ourselves as experienced professionals.
Helen MeluishI became a credentialed nurse 1 year ago and moved from acute community care to case management at the Division of General Practice where I am one of two nurses.Initially I found the transition a little difficult having always been in acute mode but one year on I think I would find it difficult to now go back. There are many benefits to working in the environment I am in. I am a truly autonomous practitioner with the support I would have liked to have in my previous role but never had access to. I now receive not only peer support but supervision, and I am continuing to learn a great deal about the way I work. In my previous role I was hungry to learn new things and to develop in my role but sadly this was never offered and I felt very much like a number. Today I am constantly learning, and in turn this makes me able to deliver a service which I feel should always have been available to our clients but never was. The client load I have is around 20 of mixed needs. The work we are able to do with our clients is positive which I hope gives them a future and choices. We have been able to enable clients to get back into the workforce, whether supported or not and we work closely with a supported workplace of which I cannot speak highly enough. We have the opportunity to not only see clients at their place of work but also to be able to provide a group environment for them which is working towards becoming totally peer led. The clients are growing in front of our eyes and that is what makes us feel like the nursing we do actually matters and brings about change. Our office environment is also wonderful with our management always very supportive of us in all we do. They allow us to get on with the job of nursing and we are no longer tied up in the red tape that had always been a barrier to care. We work in a ‘can do’ workplace. Our job of course would not be possible without the support of many excellent GP’s, the Psychiatrists and the many and varied other services which are out there providing care. I now see my role as pivotal to all the other services involved. I try to make sure everyone has the right information, that it is up to date and that we are all working towards the client’s goals. Good communication is key in providing top quality care and is the right of the client you are advocating for. With all that said I cannot forget to mention my colleague Kim. We work in different ways and have had different experiences in our nursing roles which brings about a fantastic team. We both want the absolute best for our clients and Kim is a great promoter of the good work that we do. As far as cost benefits to the system we are of course saving a lot in reduction of bed days. This is backed up by information by our supported workplace that shows reduced absenteeism from their workplace and reduced hospital admissions. It is however difficult to attract nurses into our workplace due to the lengthy and time consuming credentialing process. A positive change in this area would make it easier to increase our workforce. Pay is another reason why attraction can be difficult as the pay should reflect what nurses are able to achieve in the public setting and not pay less. You are of course asking for a highly qualified nurse to work autonomously and provide an excellent service. Therefore if you want a good nurse you really need to pay the money to reflect that. Finally the referral system to the MHNIP program could be simplified. Many of our referrals can come via non-eligible organizations (Primary mental health care providers e.g. NGO’s) and these clients do not often have GP’s. Therefore to widen the referral system to be initially assessed by the us at the Division and then to link them with a GP could be more appropriate. Eligible organizations could be expanded to include supported workplace environments, primary healthcare organizations and the mental health nurses themselves should be able to work independently of the GP’s.
Sharon BoothI have been working in the MHNIP since its inception. The program has been wonderful for clients; their families the medical staff in the community, NGO's and of course the nurses.Clients The clients receive a specialised service that is focused on their needs. This includes mental health assessment, risk assessment, needs assessment, counselling, medication monitoring and mental state monitoring as well as psychoeducation and substance abuse treatments. I provide consults, liaison with family, key stake holders and the primary practitioner. I refer clients for specialist consults when required,(e.g). neurology, cardiologist, dietician etc., and to clinics and programs that include issues like sexual assault, domestic violence eating disorders. The clients get an holistic service and have longitudinal care which is not able to be provided through the public health system and is not provided by the GP. Clients can have long appointments with their nurses and not rushed in and out. They can remain within the program as their needs require and it is cost neutral to mental health clients almost all who have a disadvantaged financial situation. The families feel strengthened by the support of the experienced mental health nurse with whom they can share their experiences and concerns. This enables a wider support system for the client when the family can be involved with the nurses in helping the client to achieve their optimum functioning. If families have concerns about the illness they can have it explained which will include strategies to assist the client to keep well. GPs The GP involvement is also supported by a specialist clinician nurse. With the nurse monitoring the clients and their mental state, issues can be addressed in a more timely fashion in many cases, thus keeping them out of acute care in the local hospital and saving valuable public health care dollars. The numbers of hospital days overall are reduced when clients have assertive care in the community either by preventing the need for admissions or allowing the client to be discharged to responsible professionals in the community. NGOs The NGOs have embraced the program as the specialist mental health nurses have been supportive in the care and management of the issues that the clients face with housing, employment, medication management, financial issues, and social issues. These basic needs we take for granted but are huge issues for persons with mental illness who cannot always advocate and negotiate these things for themselves. Nurses What I like about the program is that it allows me autonomy; I have my own consulting rooms centrally located to local mental health services, and public transport. I love the engagement with the clients and their families. It raises the self esteem of clients that someone is actively caring for them and I have had lots of positive feedback from families who are thankful to have a mental health nurse who understands the issues caring for their loved one. In my role supporting other health professionals, I provide education for the GP's and practice nurses. I conduct case presentations and reviews which often includes the client and family as well as NGO partners. I assist the GP with medication management issues and refer as necessary to the consultant psychiatrist for review. Improvements neededThe program needs to encourage more mental health nurses into practice. We need education support, we can provide role modelling and clinical placements supported through the schools of nursing. The HoNOS does not accurately reflect functional improvements in the client as it is subject to the person completing the assessment. A more accurate measure would be a questionnaire that the client can respond to and also to include how having their own mental health nurse supports them in the community when in crisis. We desperately need to increase the number of sessions as currently 10 is not enough given the demand on our services. I often work a 10 hr day and with only 10 sessions this fills only 3 days a week. The fact that session numbers are capped, and the remuneration is also capped is unique in that no other profession has restrictions on their provision of services. The program has been a success so it's time to broaden the parameters given the benefits to the clients and society. Sharon Booth FACMHN Clinical Nurse Consultant Psychiatric Emergency Care Centre, Wyong Hospital NSCCAHS
Linet HilsbergWhy I like working in the program:
Benefits of the program
Client satisfaction
Improvements needed
John WalkerFrom my experience, MHNIP:
Practising under the MHNIP, I have learnt so much more about so called ` mental illness` and developed a healthier and broader skills and knowledge base from which to assist people. I have found that; the deeper one gets to know a person, the less Mental illness one finds; however the more social, spiritual, emotional, and developmental debilitation becomes evident. People are often ignorant of so many of the understandings of social mores, hygienic practices, interactional patterns, sexual norms, and a host of general behavioural expectations. I have learnt also that people like to be treated as if they fit into the community, not as if they are different from it. We, the nurses and other health professionals in our practice, de-mystify mental illness at every opportunity, and seek to assist the general public to recognise the person who is suffering is primarily that, a person, not an illness. There is a much lower understanding of mental illness in our community than you would think; it seems imperative at times that addressing this lack of knowledge needs to become a primary focus for the Credentialed Mental Health Nurse.
Activities that have evidenced people benefits, satisfaction, and have cost benefits for the health system Under the MHNIP we have been able to use a range of activities that have had benefits for the people we work with and for the health system. We have
What could be improved?
We find that the majority of people we support have little ‘meaningful activity` during the day. Many of them want to find some kind of work; others have talents and / or skills that they would like to utilise, and develop further; others just sit around aimlessly, unconvinced of the need to do much at all. Many are socially isolated, despite living in dense suburban areas, they all want contact with others, and something to do, but find it difficult to self initiate change. Everything we do is aimed at integrating individuals into their community, assisting them to developing social, financial, and personal capabilities, repairing relationships, and to become meaningful members of society. That`s got to be saving dollars! Our practice has a few projects that we would like to develop, that will respond to the issues above, and involve most of the people we care for, however these will be time consuming, and it is financially improbable that we could get them off the ground without aid. We want to do more.
Finally Credentialed nurses have the capacity to promote 21st century mental health practice, and lead by example, in order to participate in the profound changes that need to and will occur, in the future of general and mental health. I am deeply concerned that the title of Credentialed Mental Health Nurse can be given to young inexperienced practitioners after only three years of experience in the profession. John Walker Practice Manager, Improving Outcomes, Melbourne
Ainslie Ivin-SmithI have been working as a mental health nurse under the MHNIP for over 2 years, in a rural area in New South Wales. In that time I have experienced its benefits on clinical, professional and personal levels.MHNIP provides people with the opportunity to access mental health care in the primary health setting. It serves to reduce the stigma people feel accessing psychiatric care at the “mental health centre”. MHNIP enables clients to receive expert treatment from their trusted local GP surgery. MHNIP provides better access to mental health care. I deliver care to people who may not meet criteria for access to a mental health service provided by Area Health Networks. MHNIP can be considered as a safety net for those who may fall through ”the cracks” of other treatment providers. I can attest to this as I have worked previously in the public mental health system and can now find myself able to work with people with mental health needs who are also struggling with addiction and dependency issues, whose care is often traded between agencies. MHNIP provides an alternative treatment pathway in the delivery of effective and timely mental health care. The benefit of having direct and frequent communication with the patients treating doctor underpins the MHNIP. Decisions can be made in collaboration, and treatment plans altered with immediacy. GP’s are unburdened by long consultations, which can be attended by the MHNIP, allows greater throughput and ability to see more patients. The G.P.s’ value my clinical support and the ability to refer to me someone who requires much more time in assessment and mental health care than they can generally provide. I enjoy working collaboratively with the doctors, who I have built positive professional regard. I am not bound by multi tiered, complicated entry systems, which can inhibit a person’s ability to access care. I can see people in a timely manner, and be very flexible in my clinical delivery. Working in primary care promotes a more holistic perspective, as I am mindful of the impact of ones physical health on a person’s mental health, as well as the potential impact of mental illness on the body. I have had the privilege of working in an aboriginal medical service, something normally not possible as a non-indigenous person. I learned some invaluable lessons, and experienced what it might feel like to be in the minority. I was challenged to develop new ways of working that would meet the needs of the client population. They appreciated being able to receive mental health care in an environment where they felt comfortable, able to tell their story, outside the mainstream system, where stigma, and racial issues sometimes remain. The success of the programme is evidenced by the continued referrals from G.P’s and the community mental health service via the GP. The demand on the MHNIP service is such that I could extend my clinical practice. I am currently aware of G.P’s who would like to access the support of a MHNIP nurse, but are restricted due to a lack of nurses working under the programme. Some challenges for improving the programme would be in administration, in the way sessional information is recorded, and delivered to Medicare. I enjoy being able to set the parameters of my practice, within the broad scope of the MHNIP guidelines. I enjoy the level of autonomy afforded me, and value the flexibility in my role. I appreciate being recognized for my contribution, through increased salary. I am excited by the future possibilities and opportunities that may develop through working under the MHNIP.
Birgit SchaedlerThe MHNIP has great potential to show case true holistic care for persons diagnosed with a variety of mental health problems. It is this potential and an outstanding program coordinator at our local GP Network that made me come back to the program after initial disillusionment.Having worked in the Public system for many years, I find it particularly refreshing that I can now concentrate on the person rather than the diagnosis. Being able to engage with a varied population on an outreach basis was at first a little daunting, however, the benefits are extensive. Seeing people in their own home for an assessment rather than a busy ED gives as we all know, a much better ‘big picture view’ of needs to address, in my view that is where the strength of Credentialed Mental Health Nurses lie. It has encouraged me to broader my knowledge base and skills, in order to enhance recovery. Talking about true lifestyle changes and helping set and achieve them is very rewarding. So too, is the ability to work with families and other professionals. The ability to engage in practical learning strategies with the client is invaluable and very helpful in creating a good working relationship, by allowing the client to be themselves. A further advantage is the ability to work with a limited number of clients at a given time, rather than having to accept a huge case load which does not allow for much client centered care. Not being attached to a single GP clinic allows me to work in a variety of settings, including Headspace, PSS and private Psychiatrists, which allows me to widen the circle of communication. Other mental health providers were initially surprised to hear from me requesting contact to unify the care provided, but now find it helpful and so do the clients. I count myself very lucky to be able to provide a holistic service to my clients, to learn new skills and use them, rather than being part of the slow skill erosion which has very much affected the work of some MHN working in the public system. Obviously I do have a wish list of improvements to the program. Firstly, let’s make it a true MHNIP by providing the financial incentive to the nurse rather than the GP. Initially I found it very odd that the supposed specialist (MHN) has to be ‘supervised’ and is dependent on the non specialist. However, taking steps to remedy this has slowly encouraged more professional respect from some GPs. Sadly that has no impact to whom the set up incentive monies go. The claim system could do with a fresh view – many clients need more time initially and sometimes you only get to see one per session, especially if you work with a limited number of clients. Maybe we could move away from a strict sessional approach and introduce flexibility to allow per appointment claims, as in ATAPS. Otherwise there is a danger that a good program can deteriorate into just another throughput model and that does not benefit the client either. Despite this, I believe that by standing up for our (MHN) professional values and by taking initiative we, as MHNs, have a wonderful chance to grow and contribute like never before. Birgit Schaedler has worked as part of a CAT service in the community and the ED for the last 10 years. It was during this time and initial time spent working in an acute unit that the thought crystallized, that we are missing a large part of the big picture in the treatment of mental illness. Birgit has made every effort to continue her education in a variety of counselling approaches, as well as natural therapies – including nutritional medicine. She hopes that these efforts will eventually bear fruit by becoming more widely used tools and will benefit the recovery for persons with mental health problems. At present she works three to five sessions per week in the MHNIP and has designed and is running a Wellbeing Group at a private mental health facility twice a week.
Anne HamiltonRecently, I began working part time in the MHNIP with a GP Division in Adelaide. I started on 15 hours per week, but because of the work load I had to increase my hours. I am happy to be doing this work. However, my experience outlines some of the handicaps encountered that impact on an even better MHNIP service.I have not had the length of time yet to fully develop my role, and to formulate a workable service plan with each client. With orientation, reading, prioritising clients etc., it has been difficult to touch base with GPs, other health and support workers, and NGOs, with whom I can work. Establishing rapport is essentially the main focus of my first assessment/ intervention. I have taken over from a 'contract' clinician, who left prior to my being employed. I did not have the benefit of a 'hand-over' and it is necessary to reassess all the clients. Documentation history is passable but minimal. It will take me at least 6 months to get the old clients re-assessed and, in between, visit new ones referred by GPs. When I get to see the 28 plus doctors in the clinics of the Division is a question of time. I am making house calls for assessments, in the 3-4 suburbs of the Division and there are other areas, as yet unexplored, for home visits. I can also see clients in the Divisional office, although I do like to home visit which gives me a holistic understanding of the client's respective living environment. It also helps those many clients are so financially disadvantaged that transport is a significant issue. I had a meeting last week with a team leader who told me that there is no one else who can be employed as qualified as I am being a Credentialed Mental Health Nurse. However, my pay rate is $36.04/hour, $5/ hour less than the State award I was paid previously. Having said all of the above, I am not discontented. I love the work and have supportive colleagues which are a real bonus.
Helen ReevesSoon after I began working under this initiative I remember writing an abstract for a conference titled "A psych nurse feeling alone". Understanding how to put this new opportunity into practice in the early days was a little daunting. Negotiating with GPs, working out a model for practice and payment etc. took time. Almost three years on for me, and most of these issues have been resolved.Delights of working under MHNIP:
Not so delightful:
How wonderful to so easily put together a list of why my work is so enjoyable. All of the above have just rolled off. With reflection and time, I could without doubt, add more to this list. I would certainly enjoy increased remuneration, especially not having had any increase in payment in nearly three years. However, this alone is not sufficient to deter from the pleasure of going to work, to see patients I am happy to see, for an amount of time I am cheerfully willing and able to spend with them, in a setting appropriate to their needs, under a framework that promotes recovery and reduces stigma, and secure in the knowledge I do not have an enormous backlog of paperwork to complete!
|



